jump to navigation

Matt Rossi is Wrong July 7, 2012

Posted by Stormy in Raiding.
trackback

(Provocative title! Hey, I have no shame.)

Earlier this week, Matt Rossi of WoW Insider published an article called “Attunements and why they must never return.” His thesis basically boiled down to, in his words, “attunements existed to keep you from doing what you wanted to do until you’d done what you didn’t.” On the surface, I can see that. I’m sure there’s nothing more frustrating than zoning into Eye of Eternity all prepared to take down Malygos, then find out no one has the key to the Focusing Iris. I’ve spent many hours grinding through the seemingly endless Therazane quest chain to unlock shoulder enchants just to be able to step into a raid, any raid, and I’ll be the first to say it wasn’t any fun.

However, if attunements are done properly, they represent a unique opportunity to do one thing Blizzard has been roundly (and rightly) criticized for in Cataclysm: tell a story. While Cataclysm succeeded in a lot of areas, it completely crashed and burned when it came to telling the story of Deathwing and why it was imperative for the mortal races of Azeroth to kill him. It failed to tell the story of Cairne Bloodhoof’s premature demise, the story of the reanimation of Nefarian, the story of the showdown between the chromatic dragonflight and the Wyrmrest Accord, and unless you were a DPS caster, the story of Kalecgos’s ascension to the Aspect of Magic. There are thousands of clueless players meandering around Thunder Bluff with no idea who Baine Bloodhoof is and why he’s replaced Cairne–unless they read the book.

In Wrath the Lich King lurked around every corner and occasionally jumped out to yell “Boo!” He showed up in tons of quest chains and at least two dungeons to scare the bejeezus out of you and flex his muscles as the Big Bad Guy Who Must Be Stopped. When I stepped into Icecrown Citadel I knew that the Lich King was the supreme overlord of the Scourge and I had a clear goal: to save Azeroth from catastrophic destruction,  the Lich King must die.

In Cataclysm, on the other hand, I had the opposite experience: when I zoned into Bastion of Twilight there was a giant dragon…in a hallway. Who was the dragon? Why was he just hanging out in a hallway, waiting to be killed? The game provided zero context for the existence of these dragons, zero context for the existence of Magmaw and the Omnotron Defense System. There was no reason to kill these guys except to collect their shiny purples. Absent this context, it seems like it would be a whole lot easier for Blizzard just to keep dreaming up bigger, better bosses and planting them in nondescript grey boxes just so they can be killed for loot. Absent an in-game storyline, Deathwing is just a loot pinata. Perhaps there’s some appeal there. Perhaps there are people out there who would just as soon skip the entire leveling and gearing process, start out as a fully-geared 85 and kill dragons in grey boxes for loot.

But it’s a missed opportunity. I’m sad that I never got to complete the Onyxia attunement and unmask Katrana Prestor in front of all of Stormwind. By the time I killed Onyxia in the level 80 version, she was just a big, bad dragon hanging out in a hidey-hole in Dustwallow Marsh, not the devious, scheming villainess who quietly pulled the strings of her Stormwind marionette troupe for years. I killed her, but I killed her for the achievement and the loot, not because she presented a credible threat to the survival of the mortal races of Azeroth. If we’re not going to examine the “why” behind killing Azeroth’s Big Bads, why bother to kill them?

Advertisements

Comments»

1. Pam - July 8, 2012

I loved attunements. I loved getting attuned for Onyxia, Karazhan and Black Temple. It made me feel like I was accomplishing something and, as you pointed out, it furthered the story.

I do understand some of the arguments against attunements as well. I made recruitment more difficult – if you were raiding tier 6, you would either be restricted to recruiting people who were also at that level, or forced to spend a significant amount of raid time to go back to clear T5 content and get people their vials. Attunements can also be less enjoyable for those who like the raid on multiple alts. Getting attuned for Kara once is fun, doing it a 2nd, 3rd and 4th time is much less fun.

However, I think these concerns can be addressed without leaving out attunements entirely. You could only have to do an attunement once per account, rather than per character. The steps to attunements could also be limited to solo/dungeon content, to avoid the problems seen in tier 6.

I’d love to see more story behind the bosses we need to defeat in raids. I think attunements that involved story-rich quest lines and dungeons, along with some quest or dungeon-based skill tests would really enhance the raiding experience.

Ben - July 9, 2012

I think there’s also potential for including some of the story based elements in the raids themselves.
We know why we were going after The Lich King, and if you had some knowledge of lore you’d understand who the San’Layn and Sapphiron were, but what about the Green Dragon Healing boss? What about Lady Deathwhisper?
What if there was a quest chain as you progress through the raid. Maybe each quest provides you a “Lore book” upon completion that details the how and why each boss came to be in this particular location.

2. Hasteur - July 9, 2012

Thank you for the wonderful article. We decided to feature it on Group Quest Episode 74 (to be published later this week).

3. Roldarin - July 10, 2012

Some raid lore comes from the zone quests where the raid exists, although not enough. In WotLK, the ICC dungeons added some pre-story, again, not enough. The Thrall story ending in the DS dungeons in Cataclysm probably was the best so far.

Rift added solo/small group dungeons which were intended to give lore/background to their raids. It would be cool to see if end-game scenarios could fill this function in addition to dailies and 5 mans. Either prepare people for certain raid mechanics. Or give some background.

4. Berni - July 13, 2012

I’ve been reading a lot of Rossi’s articles lately, and both the attunement one and the hardcore raiding one he posted the other day annoyed me quite a bit. While I can appreciate his opinions as his own in both, the articles are written quite poorly. They never seem to have a point other than to rant or ramble about the topic. Neither article has a clear thesis, and neither one of them presents a counterpoint with some effort behind it. I’m okay with a person having those opinions, but I’m not okay with someone treating his opinions like an objective measure on how everyone else has experienced the game for the past 7 years.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: